Mind the (converging) Gap

5 min read 30 Apr 21

Summary: Nine months ago, I wrote a piece arguing why I believe 2020s will be the decade of the cheap asset

This was at a time financial media was awash with headlines that read ‘the death of value’. We saw this as the market capitulating at the end of a decade long underperformance for the style. After seeing initial recovery last September, and more violent moves since the positive news on COVID vaccines last November, now it would be hard to find a strategy note that doesn’t talk about the great value rotation.

A regime change in the making? 

One of the strongest factors that contributed to value’s prolonged underperformance was the 40-year downward trend in global interest rate. It is, thus, not surprising that the rotation back into value is happening as we begin to see rates tick up. Although the recent spike appears quite dramatic, government bond yields are still incredibly low by historical standards. Importantly, in our view, there is little scope for them to go much lower. Therefore, irrespective of whether they rise further, we think the current situation is positive for value. We are optimistic that the prolonged headwind that value has faced over the past ten years from falling bond yields could finally be receding.

Please note, past performance is not a guide to future performance.
Source: Refinitiv DataStream, as at 12 March 2021

Another challenge for value has been the rise of monopolistic global companies that continued their exponential growth in recent years. We are seeing evidence of these companies beginning to compete with one another – such as the increasingly overlapping digital content offerings, a potential race for next generation of cars, and even the foray into digital currency. In addition, regulations are catching up with these ‘once-disruptor’ businesses. For example, governments have been investigating debit-card practices and examining the behaviours of social media enterprises. 

In our view, these combined trends represent significant opportunities for negative surprises on these over-bid companies. 

In contrast, despite the sudden and violent rotation into value, the valuation gap between the most expensive and the cheapest parts of the market has never been larger. As the chart below shows, the gap between the top and bottom quartile price-to-book ratio is still at a multi-decade high. 

Please note, past performance is not a guide to future performance. 
Source: Refinitiv DataStream, as at 31 March 2021

Some might argue that the valuation spread is due to the earnings power of the top end of the market accelerating in a changing economic environment. This is, however, not the case. While the dispersion between the most expensive and the cheapest parts of the market has steadily grown since the Global Financial Crisis (GFC), this is due, predominately, to valuation re-rating at the expensive end of the market, and less to do with actual earnings growth. For us, this means there is plenty of room for further valuation compression from the expensive end of the market. 

We believe the biggest driver for the ‘return of value’ lies in this unsustainable valuation dispersion. As the regime change gets underway, we are likely to see the source of growth change. Challenges to the sustainability of returns at the high end should cause extended valuations to retreat. While improved opportunities for return at the bottom end of the market should put upward pressure on valuations. 

As we have seen in the past several month, the snap back is already happening. It is no longer a question of when. As one sell-side research house has pointed out, ‘value stocks are now becoming the new momentum stocks’. In a desert of high-yielding assets, value stocks could be one of the last oasis to provide investors with much needed returns. 

While we are very positive on the return of the value style, we are also aware that there are many structural challenges in some of the typical value sectors. Even before COVID-19, we were seeing some very big changes in the global economic model. Now as we slowly come out of a global lock down, old and new challenges abound. In times like these, it is vital that investors remain nimble to avoid pitfalls and take advantage of new opportunities. 

In the past few years, investors would have done well from simply investing in the largest companies in the US stock market. As this trend looks to be reversing, we believe now is a particularly good time for active managers to add value. Stock picking is a delicate art of balancing risk against valuation. This art, temporarily, lost its importance when the market was supported by strong themes of abnormal growth, prolonged low interest rates and economic transformation. Ultimately though, valuation and stock picking does matter. 

Avoiding value traps

While we believe the cheapest quartile of the market is a rich hunting ground for good longer-term investment opportunities, we also recognise that there are many value traps. As more investors are looking at the style, we would caution against investing indiscriminately in cheap stocks. Stock picking in this environment is more important than ever. 

We believe the value rotation has only just begun. Despite recent recovery, value stocks have yet to recover to pre-COVID levels. 

Please note, past performance is not a guide to future performance. 
Source: Refinitiv DataStream 28 February 2021. Rebased to 1 at 28 February 2020. US Indices: Russell 1000 Value and Russell 1000 Growth, EU Indices: MSCI Europe Value and MSCI Europe Growth

As mentioned above, the valuation dispersion between value and growth was already at historical highs prior to the pandemic and subsequent lockdowns. In our opinion, this rotation could be a once in a generation opportunity for investors, and indeed, could be the start of a trend for cheap assets that defines the current decade. With careful stock selection, the opportunity ahead is truly exciting. 

By Richard Halle

The value of investments will fluctuate, which will cause prices to fall as well as rise and you may not get back the original amount you invested. Past performance is not a guide to future performance.

Related insights