Demographics and the shifting economic centre of gravity

8 min read 8 Dec 22

An update on demographics and the shifting economic centre of gravity and what they mean for Pru multi-asset portfolios?

In November, the UN’S Department of Economic and Social Affairs marked a milestone, setting 2022 as the year the world population would reach 8bn people. The geographical composition of the world’s population highlights an ongoing shift in the demographic, and economic, centre of gravity of the world. These are themes we have written about previously and are key factors that have influenced the evolution of multi asset portfolios across equity, fixed income, property and alternatives.

We reflect on the current impact of global demographics on our Capital Markets Assumptions (CMAs) and the implications this has on our outlook and investment strategy.

Few things in economic forecasting are certain. And when forecasting population growth, there are many assumptions relating to fertility rates, migration and so on that must be factored in. That said, existing population cohorts can still offer a relatively reliable indication of how the working populations of economies can be expected to evolve over coming decades. 

But why do demographic trends matter?

In fact, demographics are a key structural factor, influencing growth potential of an economy, and are thought to also have a bearing on trend inflation. These are both key inputs to our CMAs . Additionally, since savings/portfolio preferences are expected to evolve over a person’s lifetime, large-scale shifts in the relative weights of age cohorts in a population can have a large bearing on the supply of capital and the required return for particular asset classes. (this bit isn’t very clear?)

Our own in-house modelling of the potential growth of world economies features demographic projections as a key factor to the production function of economies, alongside required capital investment and productivity growth.

Figure: Annual real GDP growth projection; rolling 5-year averages measured at current Purchasing Power Parity (PPP)

Source: Datastream & LTIS calculations, as of June 2022

Looking across the different regions of the world, there are clear divergences in demographic trends, with implications for the outlook for economic growth and capital markets. Aggregating up country-level estimates, we see continue to see scope for Asian and emerging market regions to gain a larger weight in the global economy over time.

In Western economies, the post-war decades saw a burst of population growth that led working populations to grow rapidly, supporting aggregate economic growth. Recent decades have seen fertility rates in these countries fall steadily and this is bringing about a turning point for demographics in these economies on two fronts. Firstly, fewer young people are entering the workforce and secondly, a significant portion of the population is getting closer to retirement.

Other regions offer brighter prospects. As can be seen in updated projections from the UN, the geographical split of the global population is rapidly evolving, with the representation of Asian and African populations set to rise materially over the course of the coming thirty years, as birth rates for the region continue to rank as the highest and life expectancy improves.

This has certainly been reflected in our decisions to add Indian equities and Emerging Market debt while also increasing exposure to African equities, Asian property and Asian bonds, for example.

Figure: Rankings of the world’s ten most populous countries, 1990 to 2022, and UN projections for 2050

Source: UN

By extension of these demographic trends, we can expect the economic centre of gravity to also shift over time. As we have previously discussed with our work on shifting economic centre of gravity, it is easy to forget that the Western dominance of the 20th century was preceded by Eastern supremacy.

Figure: Long-run trends in regional shares of world GDP

Source: University of Groningen, 2018

And the prospects for faster economic growth are not just underpinned by more bodies on the factory floor. Since the onset of globalisation, increased economic integration and knowledge sharing has begun to bear fruit for middle- and lower-income economies. These regions also have a lower base with respect to productivity per worker; a convergence toward advanced economy productivity levels, can further raise the scope for relative outperformance.

Alongside a growing relative weight in global activity, our analysis of global trade flows indicates that a greater degree of EM trade is intra-regional between EM trade partners, also suggesting there is an increasing degree of internally-generated activity.

Whilst developed markets and in particular the US, will still have a significant bearing on emerging market economic and financial market conditions in coming years, these trends do suggest increasing scope for internally-generated demand to help emerging markets to become more independent of developed market cycles over time.

Over the long run, the market capitalisation of domestic equity and bond markets tend to be closely correlated with the size of the economy. However, when comparing the capitalisation of global markets, we see a large concentration in weight toward advanced economies, that is disproportionate to their relative economic weight, as at current levels of GDP. The contrast is even more stark when viewed in the context of contrasting growth outlooks.

Figure: Economic weight versus global equity benchmark weight

Source: Datastream & LTIS calculations, as of June 2021

Summary

The most obvious implication for our investment strategy has been the greater allocation to Asian and Emerging Markets assets (specifically India, Asia and Africa) within a global portfolio than might be expected if basing allocation weights purely on relative market capitalisation in global benchmarks.

While long term growth prospects offer compelling arguments to invest in EMs as a group, there is a fair amount of risks and uncertainty about the outcomes for specific countries. Not all of them will necessarily reach developed country status, and each of them have risk characteristics which are distinct. Hence there is a case for diversification within EMs and any concentration risk needs to be carefully monitored and managed.

Additionally, local market expertise is required for managing these investments and our preference is for managers with a local presence who understand the country-specific risks and have a track record of managing investments in these markets.

Long Term Investment Strategy is part of Investment Office of M&G. It is responsible for generating economic and capital markets assumptions, setting investment strategies and Strategic Asset Allocation for Prudential’s with-profits, annuities and unit linked products.

This document has been prepared by M&G Treasury &Investment Office (“M&G T&IO”) for informational purposes only for the sole and exclusive use of the persons to whom it is addressed and may not be passed on to any other person, as further distribution might be restricted or illegal in certain jurisdictions. This document or report may not be copied, published, circulated, reproduced or distributed without the prior written consent of M&G T&IO.

Recipients and users of this document are wholly responsible for its use and interpretation and must have due regard and attention to the recipient and user’s specific purposes and context. Interpretation is at the sole discretion of the user and M&G T&IO does not accept liability for use and/or interpretation of any of the information set out in this document. 

This document does not constitute or form part of any offer or invitation to sell, or any solicitation of any offer to purchase any security or other interests, nor shall this document or any part of it or the act of its distribution form the basis of, or be relied upon in connection with, any contract for the purchase of any such securities or other interests. This document does not constitute investment advice.

Information given in this document has been obtained from, or based upon, sources believed by M&G T&IO to be reliable and accurate although M&G T&IO does not accept liability for the accuracy of the contents. Any opinions expressed are our present opinions reflecting current market conditions, are subject to change without notice and involve a number of assumptions which may not prove valid. Past performance is no guarantee of future performance. The value of investments can fall as well as rise.

To the extent available, the industry, market and competitive position data contained in this document come from official or third party sources. Third party industry publications, studies and surveys generally state that the data contained therein have been obtained from sources believed to be reliable, but there is no guarantee of the accuracy or completeness of such data.

Where included, benchmark and index data included in this document are provided for illustrative purposes only. Every effort is made to ensure the accuracy of any information but no representation, warranty or other assurance, express or implied is made or given by M&G T&IO or any of its shareholders, affiliates, directors, employees or any other person as to the accuracy, completeness or fairness of any information, forward-looking statements or opinions contained in this document and no responsibility or liability is accepted by any of them for any such information, forward looking statements or opinions in respect of any omission, and this document is distributed expressly on the basis that it shall not give rise to any liability or obligation if, for whatever reason, any of its contents are or become inaccurate, incomplete or misleading.

Neither M&G T&IO nor any of its shareholders, affiliates, directors or employees undertake any obligation to provide the recipient with access to additional information or to correct any inaccuracies herein which may become apparent. By accepting the document, you agree to be bound by the foregoing limitations.

M&G T&IO, is registered in England and Wales, registered number 2448335, with registered offices at 10 Fenchurch Avenue, London EC3M 5AG.